The Multiplier Effect: Why Smart Marketers Are Rethinking the Brand vs Performance Media Balance

Published: April 15, 2025

Marketing executives face a persistent tension between immediate ROI and long-term brand equity. The latest WARC 2025 report, "The Multiplier Effect: A CMO's Guide to Brand-Building in the Performance Era," dispels the notion that you have to choose one or the other. Instead, the research reveals an essential strategic imperative: the deliberate integration of both approaches drives sustainable growth.

Beyond the False Dichotomy

Marketing departments have long operated with artificial divisions — brand teams in one corner, performance teams in another, each competing for budget and executive attention. This separation has created problematic imbalances, with organizations frequently over-indexing on short-term performance tactics, driven by the pressure for immediately measurable results.

The consequences are increasingly evident across the industry: diminishing returns on performance spending, escalating customer acquisition costs, and eroding brand foundations that ultimately compromise business longevity.

The Evidence for Integration

WARC's research delivers a compelling conclusion: combining long-term brand-building with short-term activation strategies delivers 2.5x higher business effects than performance marketing alone. This "multiplier effect" manifests across key metrics—accelerating sales velocity, strengthening pricing power, and establishing sustainable growth trajectories.

Airbnb exemplifies this principle with their strategic pivot during the pandemic. By reducing performance ad spend by 58% and reallocating resources toward brand storytelling, they achieved higher direct traffic and bookings. This case demonstrates how thoughtful brand investment reduces dependency on paid channels while enhancing overall business performance.

Creative Quality: The Critical Catalyst

The report emphasizes the pivotal role of creative excellence. High-quality, emotionally resonant creative work serves as a powerful catalyst for both brand building and performance outcomes. According to the research, creative quality accounts for 49% of sales lift in campaigns—a stark reminder that media efficiency without compelling creative leaves significant value unrealized.

In an economy where attention represents the scarcest resource and consumers navigate thousands of messages daily, creative quality isn't optional—it's the difference between memorability and irrelevance.

AI's Strategic Role

Evolving Measurement Frameworks

For many organizations, the greatest barrier to achieving this balanced approach lies in outdated measurement frameworks. Marketing leaders must evolve their metrics to value both immediate conversions and long-term brand equity growth. This requires:

Developing more sophisticated attribution models that account for the interplay between brand and performance
Extending measurement timeframes beyond quarterly reporting cycles
Valuing brand metrics with the same rigor as performance KPIs

Progressive marketers are implementing holistic frequency management across touchpoints, real-time reach and frequency optimization, and unified measurement across the video ecosystem. This comprehensive approach reveals the full impact of investments across both brand and performance dimensions.

The Strategic Imperative

As the marketing landscape fragments further across channels and platforms, the brands that will thrive are those that dismantle internal silos, reframe success metrics, and recognize brand-building as the essential force multiplier for performance marketing.

The evidence is definitive: the integration of brand and performance strategies drives superior business outcomes. In a business environment defined by constant change, this multiplier effect represents perhaps the most sustainable competitive advantage available to forward-thinking marketers.

For CMOs navigating this complexity, the report's message is clear: invest in creative excellence, balance short and long-term thinking, and align your organization around the multiplier effect that emerges when brand and performance strategies work in harmony. The technological foundation exists to enable this integration, allowing marketers to orchestrate campaigns effectively across channels and capture consumer attention in an increasingly competitive landscape.

The brands that embrace this integrated approach won't just compete in the attention economy—they'll WIN.

Written By: Julia Cramer

To get the latest updates on out of home advertising, digital marketing and technology, follow us on: